Skip to content

Is Jamie Dutton adopted? Who is Jamie Dutton’s father in Yellowstone?

November 10, 2021

Yellowstone is a good western drama that primarily captivates audiences by combining dysfunctional family dynamics with melodramatic narration. The Dutton family has many secrets that have surprisingly twisted the twists and turns. One of the most unexpected twists and turns in the Dutton family saga is that of Jamie Dutton’s true parentage.

The eloquent and slick lawyer who would do anything to protect his family learns a life-changing secret that completely changes his view of the duttons. The effects of that reveal are still being felt as the series picks up pace for its fourth season. If you’re looking for a refresher on Jamie’s true parentage and how it affects the duttons, here’s everything you need to know!

Is Jamie Dutton adopted?

Jamie Dutton is introduced in Yellowstone’s first season as the son of John and late wife Evelyn Dutton. Jamie is an attorney who uses his position as a means to protect his family. He resembles John in the ferocity with which he protects his siblings, but also longs for recognition and confirmation from his father. His tough nature also makes him prone to questionable decisions, not unlike John. One might assume that these similarities between the father-son duo are due to their blood relationship.

O53cBygQKBpSq0aPtKKQUiSkLLA9 DeXu3p3 2 4

So it was a huge shock to viewers when it was revealed in season three of the series that Jamie is not a biological Dutton. In the seventh episode of season 3, titled The Beating, Jamie receives a copy of his birth certificate from his assistant for a menial task. However, it turns out that his maiden name is James Michael Randall and the names of John and Evelyn are nowhere on the Dutton siblings’ birth certificates. John confirms that he and Evelyn adopted Jamie when he was just three months old.

Why did John adopt Jamie? Who is Jamie Dutton’s biological father?

After learning the truth about his parentage, an angry Jamie confronts John, who reveals the tragic circumstances of Jamie’s adoption. When Jamie was a few months old, his birth father, Garrett Randall, came home from work one day and found his wife Phyllis sleeping with another man, completely ignoring Jamie. Garrett hit Phyllis so hard that she died. Garrett was later sentenced to 30 years in prison for Phyllis’ death. After their mother died and their father was imprisoned, John and Evelyn adopted Jamie. After their confrontation, John assures Jamie that he will always be treated like a son.

QQS9m26u2nWT8 lSq5yY 3 5

However, Jamie decides to see Garrett, who reveals to him that Jamie’s mother was a drug addict and that he killed Phyllis to protect his son from a poor upbringing. Slowly, Jamie begins to befriend Garrett and confides in him what he really thinks about life on the Yellowstone Ranch. His feelings of being neglected and ignored by John lead Jamie to seek Garrett’s approval, which in turn leads to a split in his adoptive family. It remains to be seen whether Garrett really does the good influence on his son he claims to have or whether he leads Jamie down a dark path.