The Devil’s Prey is a horror film directed by Daniel Stamm about the Catholic Church’s fight against demonic possession. After the increase in such cases, the Catholic Church decides to reopen schools and train priests to exorcise demons. But a nun named Sister Ann, who has a natural talent for the complex procedure, finds herself in the spiritual limelight.
As a result, Ann must contend with a demon that has a deep connection to her past. If you enjoyed this film’s exploration of spirituality and demonic possession, you’re sure to be on the lookout for other streaming offerings of this nature. In that case, we’ve put together a list of similar films. You can watch most of these movies like Prey for the Devil on Netflix, Amazon Prime and Hulu!
7. St. Agatha (2018)
Directed by Darren Lynn Bousman, St. Agatha is a horror film set in a mid-1950s church. It is about Mary, a pregnant woman who runs away from her abusive father and seeks refuge. She finds shelter in a monastery in Georiga, but has to follow the facility’s strict rules. But what unfolds in the convent is a harrowing experience that slowly transforms Mary into an unrecognizable person.
If you like the eerie setting and spiritual themes of Prey for the Devil, but aren’t a fan of exorcisms and demonic possession, St. Agatha will suit your taste. The film features similar locations and themes, but develops a completely different character drama that keeps fans hooked to the end.
6. Incantations (2022)
The Taiwanese found footage horror film ‘Incantation’ is directed by Kevin Ko. It follows Li Ronan, a young woman who is cursed after breaking a religious taboo. Six years later, she must fight demonic forces to protect her daughter. Sharply filmed and cleverly conceived, the film explores the belief in the existence of supernatural forces and is similar to the film Prey for the Devil.
In contrast to this, however, the film shows a mother trying to keep her daughter from facing the consequences of her actions. As such, viewers who enjoyed Prey for the Devil will appreciate Incantation’s slightly different narrative and visual approach.
5. The Exorcist (1973)
‘The Exorcist’ is a supernatural horror film directed by William Friedkin. Written by William Peter Blatty, based on his 1971 novel of the same name, the film revolves around Regan, a young girl who exhibits bizarre behavior after interacting with a Ouija board. As a result, Regan’s mother seeks the help of the Catholic Church to exorcise the demon from her daughter.
If you’re a fan of classic horror movies, especially demonic possession, The Exorcist is one of the best movies in the subgenre. The film also won the Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay, making it a true classic.
4. Saint Maud (2019)
Written and directed by Rose Glass, the British psychological horror film Saint Maud is about Maud, a devout Catholic hospice nurse whose relationship with Amanda, a former dancer in her care, takes a dark turn. Maud believes she must become Amanda’s savior and free her from the demons that plague her. The film received critical acclaim throughout and dealt with similar themes as Prey for the Devil.
If you’ve seen The Devil’s Spoils and are wondering how the church’s preaching affects young people, Saint Maud offers a visually stunning and emotionally moving exploration of the subject. Aside from the above points, Morfydd makes Clark’s convincing portrayal of the reclusive young nurse Saint Maud a chilling addition to the list.
3. The Devil Inside (2012)
‘The Devil Inside’ is a found footage horror film with supernatural elements directed by William Brent Bell. The film is structured as a documentary and tells the story of Isabella, a young woman who seeks answers about the fate of her mother, who murdered three people after being possessed by a demon. As a result, Isabella becomes embroiled in a series of exorcisms that will change her perception of spirituality. As with Prey for the Devil, the emotional core of the film is formed by a mother-daughter relationship and fostered by the concept of exorcism. Therefore, both films are aesthetically similar but deliver different narratives.
2. The Nun (2018)
Directed by Corin Hardy, The Nun is a gothic film that is the fifth installment in the acclaimed The Conjuring franchise. A spin-off/precursor to The Conjuring 2, the film is set in a Romanian monastery and follows a priest and his apprentice as they investigate the death of a young nun. However, they are forced to battle an evil, supernatural force that is testing their destiny in God. The film features some spooky sequences and a tense atmosphere reminiscent of Prey for the Devil, but inverts the perception of nuns in horror films in unexpected ways.
1. The Last Exorcism (2010)
‘The Final Exorcism’ is a found footage horror film about Cotton Marcus, a disaffected evangelical minister. After years of performing exorcisms, Marcus agrees to work with filmmakers Iris and Daniel to document his final exorcism before retirement. But the search brings the trio into contact with evil. The film received positive reviews and is one of director Daniel Stamm’s finest works. It also subverts the tropes of the demonic possession subgenre, similar to Devil’s Prey. Therefore, the film takes the top spot on this list!